Books: The Lady Knight Books of 2026

Screenshot of the audiobook of ‘The Second Death of Locke’ by V.L. Bovalino. Copyright goes to the publishing company.

Hi! It’s Annie!

This year seems to have been the year for lady Knights in books and I’m thrilled! While some of the highlighted books in this genre didn’t necessarily come out this year specifically; there seemed to be an explosion of talk about medieval themed books and especially books that feature women as Knights on social media this year as well as some pretty substantial buzz about several books in particular that featured these themes. Naturally, I read pretty much all of them. Because, really, what’s better than a lady Knight? Nothing, that’s what! I remember going to Medieval Times with my Aunt a ton when I was younger and wondering, rather disappointedly, why none of the Knights that competed in the tournament were women. (As an aside-Please don’t go to Medieval Times, they’re an incredibly corrupt company who don’t pay their workers fair wages.) But books are my favorite thing and lady Knights are pretty much my other favorite thing, so this was a meeting of some of my favorite tropes in fiction to ever exist. Of course this had to become my book trope hyper-fixation of the year! Unfortunately, I seemed to have more unpopular opinions than I anticipated that I would have in this reading journey. So, in this article I’m going to rank the four most talked about lady Knight books that I read this year and give my very honest opinions.

WARNING: LIGHT SPOILERS AND UNPOPULAR OPINIONS AHEAD!!!

4. ‘The Princess Knight’ by Cait Jacobs

I wouldn’t be surprised if seeing this at the bottom of my list surprises people just as much as me not liking this book surprised myself. I wear pink pretty much every day of my life. My favorite book character is probably Evangeline Fox from ‘Once Upon a Broken Heart’. This is a book about a hyper-fem lady Knight who wears all pink and is loosely based on ‘Legally Blonde’. How could I not like this book??? I really don’t want to be mean, but I think it was because it felt a little too basic? The book has a strong idea for the plot, characters, and world building that I felt we never saw the full potential of. By the end of the book I barely felt I knew more about the main character than when we started it. The character arcs felt a little shallow and the world building is probably the piece of this novel that lacked the most development. I barely understood where we were and what the rules of this medieval kingdom or medieval school were. It also didn’t feel like the author felt much like explaining this to the audience either. Also, with this book being based off of ‘Legally Blonde’ I was expecting some more satisfactory scenes with our main character proving unfair assumptions about her incorrect by the end. We, honestly, didn’t get many moments that I really felt the true impact of the way I feel it in the court scene at the end of ‘Legally Blonde’. I really do think that what I needed from this book was more. I needed more substance, more description, and certainly more character motivations. The cover is super pretty though!

3. ‘The Knight and the Moth’ by Rachel Gillig

Please don’t kill me! I think some parts of this book were beautifully done! The world building was gorgeous and it was definitely a plot that sucked me in from page one. My issues with this book largely had to do with some pretty large tropes that were present that I am, personally, getting really tired of seeing. The first being, I’m really tired of having violence against women be the jumping off point for a novel. You might argue that this was done to present an important message, but that sort of brings me to my next point. I genuinely felt as though the author was afraid of really committing to the message of this book. I felt like I had a good idea of what the message of the book could be based off of the violence that began the book, but the closer we got to the end the more it felt like the author was avoiding saying the hard things. The character would practically run into the point and then it felt like the author would distract or add something else in so that the violence against women was less the point and more a consequence. I think women have seen enough of violence directed against women just as a consequence in a story. I truly feel that there should be a solid point to it, or it shouldn’t be present. I also didn’t love the couple. I know enemies to lovers is still the thing and I do enjoy it in some settings, but here it felt not believable. He was saying some really horrible insulting things to her in one chapter and kissing her in the next. I king of just wanted her to punch him. I see why people like this novel, but it definitely wasn’t for me. Which was kind of disappointing because I loved Bartholomew and I thought it had a really intriguing setup. The world building was so descriptive too!

2. ‘The Everlasting’ by Alix E. Harrow

I want to begin this by saying that ‘The Once and Future Witches’ is one of my favorite novels of all time. I had high expectations going into this one! Unfortunately, I did feel a little disappointed. This was another one where the set-up and world building were fantastic! I really loved the clear anti-nationalist messaging from the beginning of this book and the lessons about how we need to be more careful about believing where our history is coming from. The messages of this book were beautifully inter-woven along with the beautiful descriptions of the medieval history being shown. I loved that the Knight everyone loved so much was a woman and I thought her strength was so admirable. However, I really find it difficult to get into books with ‘Groundhog Day’ storylines. Basically stories where the characters are reliving the same day or days over and over again. They seem to get really repetitive really quickly and this book was no exception. Very quickly into the book I felt as though I was losing my attention span because of this and I felt bored for much of it. I also didn’t love the romance in this book either. I genuinely thought the MMC was kind of creepy for idolizing the FMC the way he did. He never really seemed to get to a point where he viewed her as an actual human being. He put her on this impossible pedestal and I don’t know how a healthy relationship can grow from a foundation like that. However, I do think this book did a great job trying to get across some really important things!

  1. ‘The Second Death of Locke’ by V.L. Bovalino

This was the only book of these that I truly loved. This was nearly a five star read for me although it did drag a little bit in the middle. This book established a rich fantasy world with a magic system that didn’t try to do too much so that it could be genuinely understood. At no point in this novel did I question why the magic system was working the way it was. I also absolutely adored the relationship between our FMC and MMC. This is more of a friends to lovers and I know some people have some opinions on that trope; I personally really love it! But I will say, even if you don’t like it, I felt the devotion and longing between these characters so profoundly that it would more than make up for that. Partly because it’s also a forbidden romance. I loved that our FMC was queer as well and she kicked ass more than anyone else in the book. I also fell in love with each and every side character as well as the world itself. The description of the medieval forestry was dark but in such a lush way that I wanted to get lost in it. Leaving this book felt like leaving a family, which is partly why I also loved ‘The Thief and the Traitor Bride’ so much. While it’s not a direct sequel, it still plays back into the first book and we really get to see where the characters end up. It felt like catching up with old friends. I really loved that book too and I highly, highly, recommend them both. They were some of my favorite reads this year! I hope the author writes more books in this world because I just want to keep going back to it!

I know that I liked quite a few of these books less than most people, but I still recommend everyone read all of these books! Not only do I hope that publishers view the sales as a strong interest in stories led by lady Knights, but I also think that they were all very interesting in their own ways and worth a read. I just in general have been falling headfirst into fantasy reads more and more often, so I always enjoy the experience even if I didn’t particularly love the execution. I’m actually currently re-reading my favorite childhood fantasy series, ‘Inkheart’ by Cornelia Funke, so I may post about that semi-soon. But I also want to hear from you! I’m sure many will disagree with my takes so I’m excited to hear what other people thought of these books as well!

See you across the pond!

Annie

Leave a Reply